0:00:00.086,0:00:03.746
Hi! My name is Krystian Aparta,

0:00:03.771,0:00:06.793
and I'm going to talk about[br]translating terminology.

0:00:07.800,0:00:10.243
So, as translators, we all know

0:00:10.268,0:00:13.926
that because one word[br]can mean many things,

0:00:13.951,0:00:16.481
we can't just translate a word,

0:00:16.506,0:00:20.719
but we first need to find out[br]what concept it refers to,

0:00:20.744,0:00:25.466
and then, what words are used for[br]that concept in our target language.

0:00:26.673,0:00:32.530
And it's usually enough[br]to look at the context for that.

0:00:32.555,0:00:36.500
So with a word like "mouse"[br]in the first sentence here,

0:00:36.525,0:00:42.956
from the context, we know that it[br]refers to just our general domain

0:00:42.981,0:00:45.784
of the knowledge[br]and experience with mice,

0:00:45.849,0:00:50.523
and in the second sentence, it refers[br]to a more specialized domain

0:00:50.548,0:00:52.856
of computer devices.

0:00:53.401,0:00:56.272
When we're translating a word like[br]"mouse" in the first sentence,

0:00:56.297,0:00:59.518
we just go to our general[br]knowledge of the language,

0:00:59.646,0:01:05.488
and do a so-called "literal"[br]or "word-for-word" translation.

0:01:05.830,0:01:09.218
But with a word like "mouse"[br]in the second sentence

0:01:09.243,0:01:11.462
that refers to a specialized domain,

0:01:11.487,0:01:13.937
we can't really do[br]a literal translation,

0:01:13.962,0:01:16.580
but first, we need to find out...

0:01:16.890,0:01:18.929
Well, if we didn't know[br]anything about computers,

0:01:18.954,0:01:20.396
we would need to do some research

0:01:20.421,0:01:24.856
and find out what this device[br]is called in our language.

0:01:25.496,0:01:26.734
And this is important,

0:01:26.759,0:01:31.948
because even though in English one[br]word can refer to both things,

0:01:32.092,0:01:38.494
in a foreign language the specialized term[br]can have a different, non-literal translation.

0:01:38.645,0:01:43.253
For example, in Japanese, "mouse"[br]in the rodent sense is "nezumi,"

0:01:43.333,0:01:47.944
and "mouse" as the computer[br]pointing device is "mausu."

0:01:47.969,0:01:51.104
And you can tell that "mausu"[br]and "nezumi" are totally different.

0:01:52.299,0:01:58.302
I will refer to a word that refers[br]to a specialized domain as a "term."

0:01:59.017,0:02:05.876
Now, it's usually easy to tell[br]that a word or phrase is a term.

0:02:06.162,0:02:09.066
Very often, terms are capitalized.

0:02:09.198,0:02:14.523
So, these two phrases mean[br]something completely different,

0:02:14.548,0:02:17.704
and they may have a different[br]translation in your language.

0:02:17.729,0:02:21.879
Like in Spanish, the landmark[br]sense is "la Gran Muralla China,"

0:02:21.904,0:02:24.655
and the literal translation[br]is "la pared grande,"

0:02:24.680,0:02:28.290
which is just some wall[br]in a house somewhere.

0:02:28.323,0:02:34.912
Also, words that seem difficult or[br]"sound foreign" are often terms.

0:02:34.936,0:02:38.927
So when we come across a word[br]like "velocity" or "aperture,"

0:02:38.953,0:02:43.065
we sort of get the feeling[br]that we need to look it up.

0:02:45.769,0:02:52.785
There are cases, though, where it's hard[br]to tell if a word is actually a term,

0:02:52.809,0:02:57.601
and then we need to, first, find out[br]if it does work like a term in English,

0:02:57.626,0:03:03.494
and then whether there is an established[br]translation in our target language,

0:03:03.520,0:03:06.416
or if we have to make up our own.

0:03:06.996,0:03:10.373
And I would like to share[br]an experience like this...

0:03:10.698,0:03:14.140
that happened when I was[br]reviewing the Polish translation

0:03:14.156,0:03:17.724
of Janna Levin's talk on[br]the sound of the universe

0:03:17.749,0:03:19.318
by Kinga Skorupska.

0:03:19.334,0:03:23.755
And this example is used by[br]the translator's permission.

0:03:24.562,0:03:29.475
At one point in the talk, Janna[br]Levin uses the phrase "dust lanes,"

0:03:29.500,0:03:34.459
which was translated in[br]Polish as "ścieżki pyłu,"

0:03:34.484,0:03:38.768
a literal translation that[br]basically means "paths of dust."

0:03:38.840,0:03:43.721
And because Janna Levin uses a lot of[br]specialist vocabulary in her talk,

0:03:43.746,0:03:48.607
I wasn't really sure if[br]the literal translation would work.

0:03:49.126,0:03:55.104
So, I needed to find out[br]if "dust lane" is a term.

0:03:56.089,0:03:58.509
I started by googling[br]"'dust lane' galaxy,"

0:03:58.534,0:04:04.928
and these quotation marks are there[br]to look for this exact phrase.

0:04:05.715,0:04:10.341
And I found this Wikipedia entry[br]on the Sombrero galaxy,

0:04:10.365,0:04:15.338
which did contain the term[br]"dust lane" in the same meaning.

0:04:15.723,0:04:19.854
So, this confirmed that "dust lane"[br]was indeed a term in English.

0:04:19.883,0:04:24.191
Now, I needed to find[br]the Polish translation.

0:04:24.500,0:04:30.498
And the first thing I did was to go to[br]the Polish entry on the Sombrero galaxy,

0:04:30.657,0:04:34.234
which contained this sentence,[br]translated literally as:

0:04:34.388,0:04:39.734
"is partially occluded by a belt[br](torus) of nonluminescent matter."

0:04:40.485,0:04:46.984
And at this point, "torus" seemed like a good[br]enough candidate for "dust lane" in Polish,

0:04:47.009,0:04:50.573
but I wasn't really sure if this was[br]only a word used in this article

0:04:50.598,0:04:53.676
or the established term in Polish.

0:04:54.160,0:04:58.576
And to find out about this,[br]I did another Google search,

0:04:58.744,0:05:03.251
this time in Polish,[br]for "torus galaktyka."

0:05:03.744,0:05:08.154
And I found this Wikipedia[br]entry on the Seyfert galaxy,

0:05:08.718,0:05:13.678
containing this sentence,[br]which literally translates as:

0:05:13.703,0:05:18.926
la la la, "closest vicinity of the active[br]core (known as a dust torus)."

0:05:19.434,0:05:20.505
And there!

0:05:20.974,0:05:24.807
I thought I was done,[br]and this was my translation:

0:05:24.832,0:05:30.321
"dust lane" translates as "torus[br]pyłowy" or "dust torus" in Polish.

0:05:31.020,0:05:35.527
But then I thought they[br]may not be that similar.

0:05:35.552,0:05:39.598
Because as much as a "lane,"[br]usually being straight,

0:05:39.622,0:05:42.145
can sometimes be used[br]for something circular,

0:05:42.171,0:05:46.016
a "torus" is always like a circle.

0:05:46.294,0:05:50.912
So, I needed to find out[br]if the term "dust lane" in English

0:05:50.937,0:05:55.315
was really used for[br]something circular,

0:05:55.340,0:05:58.069
like a "torus" would be.

0:06:00.007,0:06:03.911
I went to Google again, and did a[br]search for "'dust lane' galaxy,"

0:06:03.936,0:06:05.872
but this time an image search.

0:06:05.897,0:06:09.498
But all it gave me were these[br]pretty images of galaxies,

0:06:09.523,0:06:13.411
but nothing to confirm[br]or disconfirm my idea.

0:06:14.126,0:06:15.941
Then, I did another search,

0:06:15.966,0:06:18.775
for "'straight|long' dust lane',"

0:06:18.791,0:06:23.203
and this straight[br]line works like "OR."

0:06:24.572,0:06:29.294
This is because we don't usually[br]refer to circles as "straight" or "long."

0:06:29.874,0:06:34.552
This brought me to a page containing[br]images and descriptions of galaxies,

0:06:34.577,0:06:39.139
and one of the descriptions had[br]the phrase "long dust lane" in it.

0:06:39.680,0:06:44.855
But comparing the descriptions and[br]images for other galaxies on this page,

0:06:44.880,0:06:51.280
I saw that they were[br]all pretty similar.

0:06:51.305,0:06:56.872
So, "dust lane" did refer to something[br]circular in all these images.

0:06:57.041,0:07:00.662
And there, I had my term.

0:07:00.687,0:07:03.408
"Dust lane" was translated[br]as "torus pyłowy,"

0:07:03.433,0:07:06.423
or literally "dust torus," in Polish.

0:07:08.000,0:07:12.889
As translators, you probably go through[br]investigations like these all the time.

0:07:12.914,0:07:15.674
But I wanted to share[br]this story, because...

0:07:17.945,0:07:23.127
Outsmarting a talk that wants[br]to hide away a term from me

0:07:24.270,0:07:30.380
is, to me, one of the most exciting[br]parts of the process of translation.

0:07:30.896,0:07:32.134
Thank you.